How great things don’t age: Cashmere shawl cardigan

Wednesday, January 21st 2026
||- Begin Content -||

Most of the time with stories in this series, we’ve celebrated how quality clothing becomes more beautiful with age - unlike the cheap product we see everywhere around us. It always feels like a story worth telling, one few adverts shout about. 

Today's example is slightly different. Unlike the patina on a pair of good leather shoes, or the fading on a piece of vintage outerwear, this cardigan has hardly aged at all. It's 16 years old, but doesn't look it.

The type of ageing we're celebrating today is how quality knitwear can last many years if cared for properly: through pilling and washing and moths and repairs, this cashmere shawl has stood the test of the time. 

The cardigan was a very kind gift from Michael Drake (above), back in 2009. I was still a full-time journalist, writing the blog in my spare time, and one lunch break I went over to the Drake’s tie factory to interview Michael. 

The factory was a big, open-plan affair back then - this predates Haberdasher Street. The staff were on a long platform raised above the production floor, and people like Michael Hill (now, of course, in charge) and Ann Ryley (who went to Begg & Co) had desks alongside Michael’s own area. 

We talked about many things, including how he preferred the style of the French over the Italians, and the particular delights of a 50oz silk tie. The whole place felt like the epicentre of the craft and understated elegance I aspired to. 

A few days later Michael sent me this cardigan, and it was a most unexpected and generous gift. We saw each other occasionally over the next few years, often at his favourite, the Chelsea Arts Club. 

Perhaps it was because the cardigan was a gift, and so more personal, or because it was connected to that early, formative menswear experience, but this piece has always been precious to me. I’ve looked after it fairly well as a result. 

I remember I washed it a few months in, with much trepidation. I soaked it gently in lukewarm water in the bath, with a little wool detergent. I then wrung it out gently in a towel, as I had heard someone recommend. And finally I dried it flat, slowly, on the rack that sits above our bath. 

It took an age to dry. It was probably only a couple of days, but because the rest of the family’s washing had to replace it more than once, and the cardigan then take its place again, it felt particularly drawn-out. 

As with so much however, the more time I put into it the more precious the cardigan felt. Time is precious.

Darning the thing wasn’t quite so successful. I was horrified - no actually, I was angry - when I found my first moth hole. Mostly angry at myself for not looking after it better. 

I found some similarly coloured grey wool, and I darned the hole fairly loosely. It was rough and stood out a bit, but it secured the hole. 

The next time I found damage, it was a lot worse. The whole cuff had a cut in it about an inch long, where the bastards had been chomping away all summer. Again, I confess I didn’t really do the right thing but simply lived with it for a while. My moth regime improved (tips here) but I didn’t repair the cardigan. 

Finally, the following year, I decided it was worth paying to repair it properly. So I sent it to Cashmere Circle, asking them to wash it, de-pill and repair the holes - the full revive service. The estimated cost was £87.

Unfortunately, when they received the cardigan, they identified a total of 10 holes on various parts of it. The extra cost was £88, bringing the total to £175. 

The holes were not possible to hide entirely. Above you can see the echoes of them where the yarn looks the same but the knit of the cardigan changes. They're scars, but ones I value for the story they suggest.  

It’s always a wrench when you have to spend good money on something you already own (like servicing a watch) but in the long run it’s usually worth it. 

The knit was as good as new, and I’ve continued to wear it in the same way ever since. In fact I’m wearing it right now, as I write this in the airport, preparing to fly to Pitti. I'm wearing it with a knitted T-shirt and cords, though it's more often partnered with a T-shirt and jeans, as pictured. 

I’ve continued to wash the cardigan but rarely - once a year at the most - and after depilling it once or twice in the first year (tips here) it hasn’t needed that since. I think the knit is slightly softer than it was at the beginning, but it’s really quite hard to remember. 

To me, it feels just like the same thing from 2009, except with layers of experience and meaning on top of it - and of course better value the longer I have it. 

Those old interviews with Michael Drake are worth revisiting by the way. There is one from April 2010 that expounds his opinions on dressing in general, saying things such as: “It’s not a question of having the world’s largest wardrobe, and certainly not an elaborate one. It’s a matter of the right clothes, that illustrate the inspiration and taste of the man wearing them.” Hard to argue with that. 

There’s a brief one with words from Bruce Boyer, and finally a good piece I did a couple of years later which has lines such as: “The French like that old English, school look. The Italians, apart from Naples of course, are much more fitted, more self-conscious and deliberately sharper.”

All good stuff, and nice to have it still available for reference. 

The cardigan is an old model, and a different fit from the current Drake’s cardigans. It also originally had leather football buttons; I replaced them after a few years. 

The other clothes shown are a white PS Tapered T-shirt, old Levi’s Vintage Clothing jeans, Alden LHS snuff-suede loafers and a Frank Clegg tote.

Care links:

Subscribe
Notify of
guest

65 Comments
Oldest
Newest
Andrew B

Hi Simon. What a nice article. I think I have the same one, that I haven’t worn for a few years because my wife half jokingly calls it La Giacca del Nonno. Your article has inspired me to go down to the basement at get it out of the closet.

Andrew B

It would help more if I looked like them in it!

James

My wife had similar feelings, but after wearing mine near daily during the winter for the best part of eight years, she has finally admitted that I look good in it!
Partly I think it’s just familiarity (and sheer bloody mindedness on my part), but also the general shift to looser fitting clothes makes it look more current, and less “Nonno”.
If I followed Simon’s lead and replaced the leather buttons, that would definitely help further.

El Presidente

That cardi looks so much better with those replacement buttons! One of the things preventing me getting an old-school shawl cardi are the leather football style buttons that make it look so old-fogey-ish (and I’m no spring chicken).

JMA

Same here. Fortunately it just takes a moment to swap them for unpolished horn buttons. I did it recently to all my cardigans during the first half of a football game.

Markus S

I agree. But it is easy to find shawl-collar-cardigans with horn buttons. E.g. William Lockie at No Man Walks alone, Colhay’s, Luca Faloni, A&S or Thom Sweeney or William Crabtree.

Andrew B

I think them same. I may change over mine too.

Lee Hulbert

What on Earth is wrong with football buttons, everybody? They’re just correct (in the French sense).

B

Hi Simon, great article!

Just one little note for “ had desks their alongside Michael’s own area.” Shouldn’t it either be “had their desks alongside” or “had desks there alongside”?

JJ

In my view, nurturing and maintaining a special piece of clothing is so much more rewarding than buying something brand new – the depth and character that cardigan has gained over the years, including the repaired moth holes, are what good clothing is all about. One can only hope that whomever inherits the cardigan from you one day looks after it as much as you have!

Cody Lawrence

Simon,
I have a ridiculously large wardrobe of carefully curated components, but virtually every post you produce confirms that yours relegates mine to the domain of a precocious 18 year old.

Just extraordinary!

Anton

Perfect fit on the denim. I so wish I could find some that fit me like that

?

Hi Anton. Have you tried Resolute 710? They come in a range of sizes from 26 to 40 inch waist with increments of an inch in general. Depending on the waist size there is a choice of 5 to 8 leg lengths. A total of 87 permutations. This model is based on a Levi’s 501 from 1966. Resolute’s philosophy, led by designer Yoshiyuki Hayashi, is to provide a perfect, tailored fit without needing hemming or alterations, allowing the denim to age naturally from the start.

Lukas

Very cool. How is the fit different from their current cardigans?

Janek K

Would you mind compare and contrasting it to the PS shawl cardigan?

Janek K

Apologies, I missed that. thank you.

Vas

Hi Simon,

Are you referring to the standard cardigans of Rubato, or the fit of their knitwear in general?

As I can’t find a shawl cardigan offered by Rubato currently or in the recent past from memory.

Al

Hi Simon. Thanks for another great article on the theme. I’m in the process of replacing the football buttons on my wool shawl from William Lockie to something similar. Would you advice to use the same diameter as the fotboll ones for the new buttons?

Aaron D

It’s reassuring to hear you felt angry about the moth holes. I ended up with a somewhat sizable hole in my Drake’s purple silk-cashmere scarf and even after I had it repaired I felt angry and couldn’t bring myself to wear it for ages even though a good job was done repairing it (especially considering the fineness). I still haven’t got the front of my Drake’s argyle jumper repaired. I think that one may actually have been carpet beetles. I felt a bit silly feeling angry about it as at the end of the day it’s just clothes but when it’s expensive and not necessarily available to buy again it is certainly frustrating.

JL

I feel your pain brother. THIS CITY AND ITS F***ING MOTHS!!! Joking apart, spoke to the senior guys at Jeeves and they say they feel that the moth problem is getting materially worse each year in London, for reasons they can’t quite fathom. I spend a fair bit of time in LA and they really don’t seem to exist, or if they do, they aren’t quite such a menace and don’t seem to breed at the same rate. O tempora o mores.
p.s. the biggest piece of advice Jeeves gave me was ‘get rid of all carpets!’

Jeldrik

How often have you actually worn it in recent years?

andres lucas

Simon, this was a great article. Well done!

Mike

“It’s always a wrench when you have to spend good money on something you already own (like servicing a watch) but in the long run it’s usually worth it.”

While I see your point, there are 2 important counterpoints (which you highlight with the last point):
– it’s usually much cheaper to repair than to replace
– the maintenance of cherished pieces that age (or not!) is rewarding in and of itself; perhaps it’s less exciting than novelty but it’s how things can become “permanent” in ones life

[As an aside, and not intended to be snarky, but I find it a little funny to see you bristling at. £200 repair, given extravagances elsewhere, particularly for a piece that was a gift in the first place – perhaps that’s a more provocative or revealing statement than the grumble it was meant to be, or maybe I’m just reading it that way!]

Alex

Hello Simon. How do you like to wear this vs your “indulgent” cardigan?

Thorh

I’ve some lovely knitwear but can’t wear it for relaxing at home. My cats enjoy being stroked too much. I’ve dedicated an old Uniqlo sweater to be my lounging around garment. It’s known as the cat-proof sweater as they can’t really damage it further than they already have.

Shawn Adkins

Great article, Simon! This reminds me… Speaking of holes in knitwear, I sent a couple sweaters to Alterknit in NY a while back to have some holes repaired, depilling, and I even had the sleeves shortened on a super thick Ezra Fitch sweater that I bought about 20 years ago. They did a fantastic job and I highly recommend them.
By the way, I am really loving my Indulgent Cardigan in natural. It’s especially handy this time of year. Amazing piece!

Brian

My wife and I have accumulated a great deal of cashmere and wool over the years (most of our t-shirts are merino even). We have constantly been plagued by moths and have lost many great garments to them. Well, I say lost, but a long time ago I heard Brunello Cucinelli say something along the lines of “cashmere is never to be thrown out, the worst fate for it is a dusting cloth”. So we have resigned many garments to clothes for stacking firewood in or similar activities. At one point, however, we decided to get storage cubes from Amazon. They didn’t cost much and have proven to be the perfect solution. I also invested in plastic garment bags for all of my suits, sports jackets, and wool trousers. Admittedly our closets look more deep storage centers, but knowing we won’t loose more good clothes to moths is well worth it.

RTK

I do the same as I hate moths and other assorted clothes eating insects. All suits, jackets and natural fiber outerwear are stored in plastic or cloth suit bags. Sweaters are stored in clear plastic sweater bags. I do this as I don’t want to use toxic chemicals inside the house if at all possible.

Markus S

Another way, if you have the space, is to pack away wool / cashmere for the summer in cloth-boxes and put sheets of chemical anti-moth papers in each. They last for 3-4 months and then you can change them

I have never had problems with moths but I would not use them in my bedroom.

Vincent F

I just got a navy lambswool shawl cardigan from Drake’s yesterday and it’s so comfortable!

GH

It looks great, not purely because it is a beautiful object on you but because it looks to be part of you. If you’ll forgive me that is not always the case in your photos and I think it’s because inevitably the clothing is new. It may fit perfectly but that isn’t quite the same thing.
Very nice, including the repairs.

robert

In my youth all “woolens” were safely stored in the “cedar chest” in the summer months to stave off the moths. The more opulent homes actually had full size “cedar closets”. Today one might purchase an old trunk and line it with cedar planks. The subtle smell of cedar in a shetland sweater takes me back. Winters were harsh. The single pane windows of my school barely held the heat. In the winter most classrooms had a subtle aroma of a gerbil cage. Yeah, it was a different time.

Thomas

Nice article Simon. A product of great quality. On a related topic I am trying to find out shops preferably in London, NY or Milan or Florence that sell McGeorge of Scotland knitwear, especially their shawl collar ones. If you or your readers would assist it would be greatly appreciated.
Thanks in advance.

Thomas

Many thanks 🙏

RJ de Mans

Just a note, the revived McGeorge label isn’t the same level of quality as what used to be before it closed some decades ago.

Tom

Hi Simon,

Lovely article. What type and size of button did you use to replace the original football buttons? I have a Drake’s shawl in navy and looking to do something similar. Thanks

James

I have the same cardigan and love it dearly. It was a major purchase at the time, even if I did get it in a Drake’s sale at half price just before they discontinued this colour. I still remember Ben selling it to me and convincing me that the larger size was a better option (something I still deliberate from time to time, even 8 years alter), and saying he’d spent his recent Christmas in the same knit, worn over a pair of flannel pyjamas!
It has lasted incredibly, with only infrequent washing, no need to de-pill and fortunately no moths.
Both my kids have been wrapped in it on multiple occasions as babies, and I treasure memories of them sleeping on my chest while it was buttoned over them to keep them warm. It’s also been tough enough to serve as a makeshift blanket on car journeys as they’ve got older! Less treasured memories include washing baby vomit out of the collar on multiple occasions….
For me, the very definition of buy the best you can afford, use it, care for it and then reap the rewards.

Erik

Hi Simon
Great update. I have been following PS for maybe 10 years. And I am impressed by the work you do and the succes you have.

But….
Most of the time with stories in this series, we’ve celebrated how quality clothing becomes more beautiful with age – unlike the cheap product we see everywhere around us.
“cheap products we see everywhere around us.”
I know quality products cost money, but please, what do you really mean by that, cheap products .

Everybody should by a cardigan for 1500 quids?
I don’t think you come from a family with wealth, built up by generations, and have a SIR title, or lord.

keep it real

Ian

I’ve found that storing knitwear in zip lock plastic bags to be a very effective anti-moth strategy. I also include a silica gel sachet to avoid moisture.

RJ de Mans

Hi Simon:

What an evocative article. Every time I read you I get reminded I should do so more often. Regarding repairs, have you considered using a reknitter? I’m not sure if there is one convenient to you; it seems kind of rare nowadays, but the moth and other damage repairs they do have been pretty much flawless and invisible to my eye. I haven’t used Cashmere Circle, but from what I’ve seen I think the repairs they do are a different technique.

Martin

Hi Simon,

Very nice article. I’ve just picked up a Brunello Cucinelli cashmere one (humble brag) at a thrifty price and I can’t wait to start wearing it. The fit feels great.

It seems to have been raining in the UK for about two months now so I haven’t quite found the right day of environment for it yet!

ANONYMOUS

Simon do you see shawl collar cardigans with larger armholes than needed as a natural look? Or do you look for one with a more fitted armhole? It seems that many shawl cardigan offerings have rather large armholes.

Anonymous

Simon, I’m just wondering what your thoughts are on the design of the Connolly City cardigan,

https://www.connollyengland.com/collections/mens-knitwear/products/city-cardigan-navy