A guide to knitted T-shirts
By Manish Puri.
The only suit you’ll ever need. Five hacks to up your style game. The ultimate summer wardrobe cheat code.
These are headlines you’re unlikely to ever see on Permanent Style - and if you do it probably means Hell has finally been able to open that ski resort.
The promise of one-size-fits-all fixes just isn’t the way we like to play the game. Because, to quote Denzel Washington’s magnificently malevolent Alonzo Harris in Training Day: This shit’s chess. It ain’t checkers.
Developing your style and wardrobe is about more than just trying to bluff your way to a quick fire checkmate. It’s about relishing the mid-game: evaluating the board, considering the permutations, and then assiduously building your position to one of such strength that the outcome becomes inevitable.
But, everyone has to start somewhere. Every player needs a solid opening.
In a starter wardrobe, that might translate to an upgrade of a basic - elevating the quality, fit or style of something like the humble T-shirt, which, while perfectly fine in its simplest form, can be harder to pair with a more tailored wardrobe.
These days there’s no shortage of options here. For the sake of brevity, I’ll refer to them in this guide as knitted T-shirts, but that’s something of a misnomer, because even the cheapest T-shirts are often jersey knits.
In this instance (and I think it’s fair to say, often across the industry) the term is shorthand for T-shirts that are made more like a quality sweater than a cheap sweatshirt. In other words they are:
- Fully-fashioned rather than cut-and-sewn, so each panel is individually knitted and linked together, rather than being cut out of a single larger piece of fabric before being sewn together.
- Finished at the edges with ribbing which allows some stretch (permitting a closer neckline that you can still get over your head) while ensuring it holds its shape on the biceps and waist.
- Made from higher grade cotton and other finer materials.
You can read more about why some of these attributes are desirable in Simon’s article about knitted, fully-fashioned T-shirts. And, more specifically, why they can be helpful in relation to tailoring here.
For now, let’s press on with a survey of the best out there. As always, I know the readership will have a wider set of recommendations than we could ever hope to include, so please do spill the tee in the comments section.
The Anthology knitted T-shirt ($120)
When searching for an all-rounder knitted T-shirt, it’s hard to look beyond The Anthology’s offering.
It’s been one of their staple products for some time (which means it’s benefitted from minor refinements, such as an increase in length, over the years), it’s fairly priced and is available in more colours than any other brand in this guide - 11 at last count, including two nautical stripes.
They’re made from a soft organic cotton that’s a little thicker and heavier than the Rubato Nonpareil T-shirt (covered later) or the new Bryceland’s Skipper Tee (£189). This lends The Anthology knit a slightly more casual air, and the additional sturdiness of the cotton also means it doesn’t need to be handled quite so delicately when laundering.
Of course, these statements need to be considered within the narrow context of this guide; compared to a High Street jersey T-shirt, The Anthology knit is still very smart, and works as well with tailoring (above) as it does with jeans (below).
In terms of fit, I size up to an Anthology large - which is almost identical in fit to my medium Rubato tee.
The only noticeable difference is the sleeve length, with The Anthology’s measuring a full centimetre longer. Ok, that’s only really “noticeable” by the forensic standard of these guides, and a non-factor when worn under a layer, but I know some readers will appreciate the heads up.
A final commendation to The Anthology for the styling inspiration found on their website.
The product page of each T-shirt showcases at least three or four entirely different ensembles - running the gamut from beach-casual to office-appropriate.
This should help stimulate ideas on how readers can wear them, and are especially helpful for the more unusual colours like rust (above) and mustard.
Nicola Radano Posidonia open-knit tee (€180)
Knitted tops have been synonymous with Italian style since the end of WWII, so it’s only right that I include at least one Italian brand in this guide.
My choice is the Posidonia tee from Nicola Radano, a Neapolitan brand whose crochet knit polo I’ve been wearing a lot recently - the waffly finish aiding breathability and adding texture.
The vertical open-weave strips of the Posidonia perform a similar function, which makes it a nice alternative to the plainer tees in this guide - perfect for someone who already has a few knits and is looking for something more distinctive.
The medium works perfectly for me. Compared to the same size from The Anthology and Rubato, the Posidonia is a bit slimmer in the chest (by 2-4cm across the half-chest measurement), but is also straighter through the body, so it’s a good option for those that prefer the proportions of a regular tee over the more exaggerated full chest-trim waist variety.
The Posidonia is also longer than those tees by 4-6cm, and that length is allowed full expression as it’s not funnelled into the waist by a tight hem.
This makes it ideal for two extremes of reader: those who want to bring a looser, longer untucked energy to their summer looks, and those who like to be able to tuck their T-shirts into their trousers. (You can do the latter with The Anthology and Rubato too, but you’ll need a higher rise).
The cotton is from Zegna’s Baruffa collection, and I have to say it feels absolutely wonderful against the skin. To my hand, it’s the softest of the cotton tees in this guide, without feeling too fine or thin.
As you’d expect from a brand whose tagline is “funky elegance”, Nicola Radano’s colour options are a bit more adventurous, but each is tempered by a sunbleached feel - think bright beach towel left behind on a deck chair in Sorrento.
The denim (above) is the sort of colour I’d advise a reader to try when they ask what they can pair with navy chinos and shorts.
Batoner High Count Linen Short Sleeve Sweater (£195)
Batoner is a Japanese brand that began life as a knitwear company before expanding into other wardrobe pieces. However, their reputation for quality knitwear remains and Simon himself has recommended them to me previously.
The High Count Short Sleeve (there’s also a long sleeve option) has been around for a few seasons, which again affords Batoner the opportunity to refine and improve it over time. This year, they’ve changed the gauge number to improve durability, and as a result the Batoner is one of the heavier T-shirts in the guide - but it’s still very breathable.
As is often the case with knitted linen, it doesn’t feel quite as cool to the touch as the woven variety (used for tailoring), and the knitting process helps draw out the texture - the Batoner has a dry, crunchy handle (even more so than the high twist Rubato Nonpareil).
In terms of sizing, the boxfresh chest fit of the size 2 is comparable to most other mediums. However, the body length is longer, similar to the Nicola Radano knit, and so has the same benefits when it comes to wearing it tucked in and untucked.
The Batoner is also wider in the shoulders with a slightly longer sleeve length. The combined impact of this is clear in the product shot above from stockist Trunk Clothiers (model is 6'1" with a chest of 38.5” wearing a size 2) - the shoulder seam sits just past the shoulders and the sleeve finishes after the bicep.
The tee also tends to stretch and lose a bit of shape during wear - which I’ve found isn’t unusual for linen tees - but will mostly shrink back when washed. However, given this natural stretch alongside the fit through the shoulders, readers might want to consider sizing down if they prefer a neater silhouette.
The Batoner collar is particularly nice - high and chunky like a sweater. The rib’s depth is 3cm which makes it the thickest in the guide alongside Rubato’s.
The colour choices (there are two stocked by Trunk and four on Batoner’s website) are the most conservative of any of the brands in the guide, essentially variants of grey, blue and black. However, Simon has one in grey which he said had a “beautiful, Armani-esque marl” to it.
There are some brighter colours available in Batoner’s other knit tee models - one made from Sea Island cotton and the other (rather fascinatingly) made from a Japanese washi paper and rayon mix.
Rubato Nonpareil T-shirt (£290)
The thing I noticed most when I received my first Rubato T-shirt was the neck opening. Measuring 11cm at its widest point (in comparison, my Uniqlo T-shirts measure 17.5cm), it appeared comically small.
And yet that neckline has proved to be one of my favourite features of the T-shirt. The cotton - a really lovely crisp, cool high-twist - offers enough stretch to pass over the head, and enough resistance to snap the ribbed neckline back into place.
The result is a T-shirt that feels as neatly fitted as a mock neck with the comfort of, well, a T-shirt.
And it’s that flattering closer, higher neckline combined with the finer cotton which makes this my preferred knitted T-shirt to wear with smart tailoring (above).
However, I also think the Nonpareil knits shine as part of the very simplest smart casual combinations - a T-shirt paired with just trousers or shorts (below).
The quality of the cotton and the higher neck help of course, but there are a couple of additional points of visual interest.
The first is the addition of a chest pocket on the left hand side - a nod to 50/60s styling, with the functional benefit of being big enough to hold a pair of sunglasses.
The second is the ribbing on the hem, sleeves and neck. Now, most knit T-shirts are ribbed, but the Rubato ribs are just a little bit meatier. Once again, it’s not a significant difference - they’re deeper by 1cm at most (or 15-20%) - but it’s these small details that add character and elevate the T-shirt when worn solo.
I’d also add that Rubato’s Marin colourway (top) is one of the best blues I’ve seen - dark enough to co-ordinate with a navy suit, but with a twinkle of indigo to stop it from looking too flat and sombre.
Connolly Cashmere & Silk T-shirt (£495)
Unsurprisingly for a garment made from 70% cashmere and 30% silk, the Connolly T-shirt feels great with a light, soft handle.
Given the lightness of the material, it also makes a good base layer, and is particularly nice for travelling - a touch of luxury and comfort that can mingle unnoticed with more casual travel gear.
While the Connolly T-shirt is true to size, it is slimmer than most of the other brands in this guide, with measurements that are probably most similar to the Posidonia knit - closer through the chest and less taper into the waist.
The sleeves are a bit slimmer too - although not to the point of restriction - and they’re finished with a shallower ribbing, which makes them look a little less vintage-inspired.
The colour choices are excellent. I think the mink (top) is very chic. And, perhaps because it’s a unisex offering, there are some bolder options - which is always welcome. My favourite, which won’t come as much of a surprise to anyone that’s read my article on pink, is the mauve (above).
I know some readers may question wearing a garment made primarily from cashmere in the summer. However, Connolly uses a very fine, light cashmere here, and (more generally) cashmere is very breathable and adept at moisture wicking. That said, we did find it slightly warmer than some of the cottons.
Honourable mentions
While I think The Anthology T-shirt represents excellent value for the quality, I know some readers would prefer a cheaper option. For them I would suggest taking a look at Arket (£47).
Of course, one can’t discuss Italian (or Italian-American) inspired knitwear without a shoutout to Scott Fraser Collection who carry an extensive selection. For crew neck tees, have a look at their Chet knit (£230) (above) and Net knit (£135), but be warned these models are more cropped than any other T-shirt in this guide.
For more non-cotton options, I’d suggest Colhay’s sport shirt (£230) (above) which is made from a merino wool from Zegna’s Baruffa Cashwool collection, and is a little thicker than the John Smedley wool. Currently only a few larger sizes are available (and I’d recommend sizing up to readers), but I’ve been told there will be a restock of select colours in July.
Thom Sweeney carries a very similar, 70/30 cashmere/silk T-shirt (£495) to Connolly. The main difference is size (the Thom Sweeney is slimmer, so I’d recommend sizing up) and the sleeve ribbing (Thom Sweeney’s is about 1cm thicker).
Manish is @the_daily_mirror on Instagram.












































We asked, he answered! I am so here for this guide – thanks, Manish.
Haha! Happy to come through for you Joe P!
Could I ask which Anthology colour you’ve found useful/enjoyed? Got my eye on the ecru and the fossil.
Two great choices! The espresso is also very nice.
Mustard was my first knitted t-shirt and is great, but it’s definitely not for everyone.
Hey Manish
Great read as always – this one was a refreshing break from the heavy luxury of the past week (though a little dreaming never hurt anyone!).
I’m a big fan of the Anthology tees and already own the ecru and navy.
Quick one for you—as a fellow South Asian with a similar complexion (and dare I say, similarly hirsute), what colors do you think suit us best? I love the rust but feel like it washes us out. Been eyeing the fossil—what do you think?
Would love your thoughts! Cheers.
Hi AK
Thank you so much.
The ecru is excellent and I think the fossil or the espresso are nice. I think the rust and the caramel might be a bit trickier for us.
Hope that helps 😊
Where does John Smedley fit into all the above?
I’m surprised that there’s little mention of John Smedley in this article??
Totally agree as I mentioned below. Top quality knits and very attractively priced.
+2. As a satisfied customer for over 30 years, I can vouch for the quality and value. John Smedley rarely lets me down and it helps being able to try on garments in the stores.
Agreed with this. Why wasn’t Smedley covered, please?
Given the framing of the article, where a person may be on their style journey, I was surprised Smedley wasn’t covered.
I also wear the ones from John Smedley for many years with great satisfaction. It’s useful to keep in mind that each blog have their business partners and preferences or like to promote newer brands for similar reasons.
Hi Anon,
I’ve had Smedley ones in the past, in case it’s helpful, and while decently made and well priced (particularly in sales) I always found the merino ones quite dry and a little tough – others often have more natural stretch. While the sea island cotton ones wrinkled a lot, because I don’t think ultrafine cotton is really what you need there. A high-twist wool or cotton (as Rubato use for example) would be better.
I’d say the Smedley polos are better on the merino side, but also still say Smedley can be a decent introduction to the category
I’ve had lots of Smedley sea island polos and they are superior to Sunspel’s. They are ideal for normal British summer temperatures and none of mine have wrinkled a lot. However, I would not wear them in very hot and/or humid weather. When the mercury rises, I reach for the Madras cotton shirts.
Thanks Kent. Yes I’d agree vs Sunspel, though I think that’s comparing fully-fashioned ones vs cut-and-sew, so slightly different categories
Simon describes well why I never wore my Smedley cotton tees. Too warm and wrinkled to wear in summer—might as well wear a l/s button down. Haven’t tried their merino variety.
Lovely post, though I’d love to see a part two to cover more variety. Many of the tees here seem like they are simply short sleeve sweaters.
Thanks Paul.
All knitted tees like this are made like short-sleeve sweaters, but I assume you mean ones that are thinner, not as thick as some of the ones here. The Rubato ones are quite fine, and Smedley’s merino ones are certainly better than the cotton
This has not been my experience and I disagree here. While JS’s 100% merino long sleeve polos are very good, I have worn an Isis for quite a while and never had any issues of this nature. I have cotton (I guess their Sea Island quality) and cotton-wool, and I never had issues with overheating (of course in 35 and above even bare skin is hot), or wrinkling too much, including under jackets. Have had full days of wearing them with good performance. Of course cotton wrinkles, but I haven’t had significant issues with JS vis a vis other makers. I wonder if this relates to a particular year of production or something. I do remember you commending them in the past, Simon, and having some favourable reviews in the past. This comes across as harsh criticism and “do not buy” advice. Grateful if you could please clarify.
Hi Stephan,
On cotton, I do honestly find in general that it’s not the best material for fine polos like this. It’s not as cool as a dry wool if made well, and wrinkles more. You may find you are cool enough, but I think you would also find a high-twist wool better on both counts.
In terms of the wool side from Smedley and recommendation in general, I still think Smedley are good and nice option. But in this article I’m talking about the T-shirts, not polos like Isis, and for those I find they don’t tend to have as much stretch as some of the ones mentioned here, and I find that detracts a bit from the comfort.
Thanks for clarifying, Simon. I may try to get a Smedley polo in wool only (I think they exist) and will compare. I do love the styling of Isis and haven’t found an alternative elsewhere. I guess your polos may be a very similar style? They are 100% wool, no?
I have yet to try the JS T-shirts, and am actually likely to place an order for a merino piece, and perhaps a merino-cotton mix. I will see how the merino option fares in comparison. Will be a nice project for the summer, and given that I like their style very much and there is a sale now should be a good way to test it.
Yes they do, but the collar is different.
Ours is closer to the Isis and yes is a wool.
Another decent cheaper option is spier and mackay. Especially if anthology is too small. Cotton is quite nice. Cotton-silk is even nicer.
Thanks Martins!
I agree. While perhaps not mentioned with the other brands of summer knitwear, I have several woven t-shirts from Spier and they are great.
Hi Manish, love the writeup as usual. Would you say any of the above would work for a hot,sweaty summer? I tend to find most knitted tees less breezy than a cut and sew tee, I’m assuming due to the weight of the knit. i.e. I’ve tried The Armoury’s ‘Ice Tee’ but was sweating like a pig in Tokyo last week
Hi Luke
It’s a good question, and something I touched on in an article I wrote about the clothes I wore in Thailand.
To be honest, in 35 degree heat and high humidity, I found knitted t-shirts a bit too good at keeping their shape and fitting the body. As a result, I didn’t wear them as much as I thought I would and turned to cheaper band t-shirts for a little looseness and breeziness.
You could size up on a knitted tee, but that negates some of the benefits of the knitted tee.
I also think the Rubato high twist was the coolest I tried, but I suspect it’s similar to the Ice Tee.
I should say that I run hot so I’d be curious what readers that live in hotter countries think.
Hope that helps 😊
Hey luke and manish, i live in singapore which is hot and perhaps more humid than Thailand. I own a mooncastle ice knit tee too and it’s just simply too hot to wear where i am. The closeness of fit means the fabric feels very scratchy and uncomfortable. I have since relegated knit tees to colder weather attire and am very happy with my uniqlo u tee shirts
Hello Manish 😎 This is me wearing PS’s The Tapered T-Shirt (untucked) in size S in the heat of high tropical summers here in India around 35 degrees celsius. I have sized up in the PS Tees for that little looseness and breeziness that is very much the key to dressing up in hot, humid & tropical countries like India. Clothes that are not too loose of course and drape well on the body. Loose clothing can look nice of course if it’s nicely done 😎
Fantastic Amit! Thanks for sharing 😊
Have a great weekend
Also a quick mention here I’ve never ever tried quality knitted t-shirts myself, but I have owned a cheaper one in the past that I really enjoyed wearing. From this list I like and browsed the Anthology ones myself. Maybe I’ll go for them sometimes.
“I’d be curious what readers that live in hotter countries think.”
For what it’s worth, I think knitted t-shirts are too hot even for nyc summers and I wouldn’t say I run too hot. I can only wear them for a couple of months a year, or as an under layer in colder weather (but then what’s the point of wearing a knitted tee as opposed to a regular one?)
I found this interesting…. Cheap ones, sure! I got a couple for 20£ from tk max. They are like chunky short sleeved jumper. But my spier and Mackay ones are much cooler than your typical Ralph Lauren Polo. And if I recall correctly, anthology ones were a bit thinner than spier and Mackay…
Do you recommend any t-shirts which can replace the knitted tee?
I do like the PS tapered T, and have worn that with relaxed tailoring
What size do you take in the tapered T, if I may ask?
A medium in that
I recommend the Filippo De Laurentiis crepe cotton and the Zanone Ice Cotton T-shirts. They are more formal than PS T-shirts but still can be easily worn by themselves. The Zanone is particularly well-suited for wearing under a jacket due to its slim fit, though I strongly recommend sizing up.
Hello Manish,
I must admit, I fail to see how a knitted T-shirt performs better than a cut and sewn one under tailoring ? Every details that differenciate it from it’s brother are hidden, smoother seams, ribbed sleeves, all is under the jacket, unseen.
Now there is the factor of higher quality cotton, but surely, such quality also exist in cut and sewn ?
To me this does nothing to prevent the main problem : crewneck don’t fit a jacket.
Those options are lovely without a jacket however, but it begs the question, at witch point does it stops being a fully fashionned T-shirt to become a cotton sweater ?
Hi Jean T
It’s a fair question, and I think there are two points:
1. I agree, quality materials do exist in cut and sew, but the number of options will likely be lower as a proportion. That’s not surprising given cut and sew is more popular and the more economical process.
2. Cut and sew is usually finished with a welt neckline, whereas most of the knitted options are ribbed. That means the knitted T-shirt should sit higher and closer to the neckline which (in theory) should frame the face more and have less chance of disappearing under the lapels of a jacket. Not that there is anything necessarily wrong with the latter – Canoshita-San often wears looser tees with lower necklines with his suits and looks fabulous.
Hope that helps 😊
Hey Jean – chipping in here, as it is a significant difference in my view. The texture is different, the collar line is different, and the drape of the material is different. Those are the only three things that you can see, and they’re all noticeably different.
You said it yourself at the end – it’s basically a thin cotton sweater, given you can’t see the sleeves. And I don’t think you’d say a sweater and a T-shirt look the same under a jacket or coat.
Of course, whether you like a crewneck at all under tailoring is a different question and probably more personal.
A fully-fashioned T-shirt becomes a sweater when it has long arms. Usually a sweater would be heavier/denser, but it doesn’t have to be.
Thank you Manish for your answers.
I do understand the idea that knitted being more “high end” sellers might be incline to choose this construction by default when dealing with premium materials.
As for welt neckline, I admit all my T I inherited from the distant time I was a highschool student (or even middle school, indeed my build never really changed through the decade) have ribbed neckline despite being around 5€.
Thank you Simon for your answer,
Indeed I forgot about the length of the sleeves, thanks for pointing that out.
I wear crewneck under tailoring, but only with a shirt underneath, button down collar or not. And I never tried cotton sweater at all, so I can’t say for sure how it looks under tailoring.
Thanks both for having taken your time to answer me.
Another brand worth looking at is Mooncastle, it’s a Japanese brand and that uses a Swiss cotton they refer to as ice cotton. The texture feels drier and cooler to the touch, less jersey like.
Thank you, Charles 😊
Personally think that the Anthology’s offering on this and several other items too are the best value propositions in the market. Great quality, fantastic design and styling, good colour ways and at a price point that feels very reasonable.
That said, for me i always find knitted t-shirts a strange choice. If I’m wearing a t-shirt with a jacket, I prefer to wear a standard t-shirt for the contrast element. If I’m wearing a t-shirt with no jacket in a totally casual outfit, I find knitted t-shirts look a bit fussy and even effeminate, with their usually cinched waist and sleeves. For me personally, they are an item that is trying to reinvent the wheel slightly. Decided this after a good two summers of trying to find ways of pairing my anthology knitted tees. Great product, just not for me.
Thanks very much, Jackson.
I agree with you on The Anthology and appreciate all your other points too.
Personally, I don’t find them effeminate worn on their own, but I can see them being seen as a touch fussy in a casual look.
Have a great weekend 😊
I feel the opposite, would never wear a normal t-shirt with a jacket, to me it looks too sloppy and pretentious at the same time (probably because it’s been done at nauseam by VIPs), and it looks like there’s too much visual empty space. But knitted tshirts solve the problem for me, they have both the comfort and the relaxed air of a t-shirt but have the much better ribbed collar and look and feel (in particular, drape) of a sweater.
The t-shirt under a tailored jkt look is very stylish but it presents the problem of a dirty collar .
After all showing shirt collar and sleeve is functional (avoid jkt coming into contact with skin ) rather then form .
Thank you for the mention of Arket otherwise the most recent articles were reading like a shopping list for Jeff Bezos (£900 shirts, £4000 shoes , £295 plus t-shirts )
Thanks Robin! That’s fair, and definitely worth keeping in mind if going for a t-shirt and light jacket look. Using a little necker/bandana round the neck can help in this regard too.
Cheers!
> Thank you for the mention of Arket otherwise the most recent articles were reading like a shopping list for Jeff Bezos (£900 shirts, £4000 shoes , £295 plus t-shirts )That’s the whole point of this website.
Some nice stuff on here but for value I always go John Smedley.
Me too, the value is excellent when the summer sale is on. It’s now on with 40% off some of the classic styles so I’m going to the Jermyn Street store tomorrow.
Hi Manish,
When would you pick a Rubato tee over an Anthology one? I know you suggested the heavier weight of TA tees make them slightly more casual but wondered how that translates to your general wear.
Secondly have you tried the Suitsupply cotton and silk tees? I know you’re a fan of their equivalent knitted shirts (as am I).
Hi Richard
I’d go for Rubato for the smarter looks – tailoring and smart casual looks. But, as I mentioned, it’s not that The Anthology shirts can’t be called into action for those looks.
Another factor is colours. Rubato only have a few colours and some of them change year on year. While The Anthology have a consistent and wider range – so part of the decision is just “what do I like/need”
I must say, I haven’t tried the SS ones, but I should! I like my knitted shirt a lot – I don’t really see much silkiness in it, but that’s not a massive issue given the price point.
I have an Anthology knitted t-shirt and love it, although I struggle to figure out what it looks best with. I sometimes feel that it looks a little feminine.
On the SS cotton and silk ones, I recently bought two in the light of experience with their cotton/silk polos, which I’ve found to be excellent and work well with tailoring. The t-shirts are nice, but I’d prefer a tighter, higher neck line. I don’t think I’ll wear them as much as I will the polos.
Excellent overview and stellar and very entertaining writing as always. I’ve been through a bunch of tee upgrades and have to say that I agree with all of this. Anthology is best value in my opinion, but the Rubato product just works better for me. I bought one and immediately knew after a couple of wears that it was what I wanted. Was fortunate enough to grab a few colors before the pricing jumped in the US (which has been discussed ad nauseam in other posts here, don’t want to go there again). I have their black (noir) version of this and it is my most worn by far in the category. I also like the Thom Sweeney versions with the higher neckline. I love Colhay’s merino but can’t wear them in the humidity of a mid-south US summer. They are fantastic for cooler spring and early fall. And yes, I have plenty of cut and sewn and find them terrific as well (PS tapered tee in every color, several long and short sleeve Real McCoy’s loop wheel). But I find that I have very useful need for both types.
Thank you so much, Chris 😊
And thank you for your own excellent overview! Super helpful.
Have a lovely weekend
At the risk of sounding like an OBN, thank you Manish for another well written, entertaining article.
Given you are size L in the Anthology offering, what size works best for you in the Rubato?
Hi Philip
Thank you so much 😊
A solid medium in the Rubato
Great overview, Manish.
Of the above, I have the knit t-shirt from The Anthology and the Colhay’s. The Colhay’s is my favourite in terms of style, but it’s helpful to point out that it’s very warm for a t-shirt, which limits its usability quite a bit.
Another brand I can recommend ist Artknit. They have linen, cotton and wool knit t-shirt. The fit is somewhat looser, which I like in some combinations.
Another manufacturer is Besnard, which this season only offers navy striped T-shirts in different colours and with different stripes. I have one of these and I particularly like the fact (as with Colhay) that the sleeves are slightly longer.
Thank you Markus S! Great additions for the readers.
Have a lovely weekend 😊
I would also recommend the Artknit linnen-cotton shirts for (really) warm weather. The fit is fairly loose and the texture is nice and dry and open. Not the softest available but comfortable enough for me and at a very agreeable price point
Another enjoyable article Manish. You are right – the Anthology website has some great styling suggestions. Lots of the pictures appear to feature Simon. Is this Anthology T Shirt a PS collaboration? If not, would PS ever consider producing its own version?
Thanks so much Christopher 😊
I don’t think it was – although PS have collaborated with the Anthology on polo coats. I think they might have been taken when they released a slightly longer T (I know Simon found the original 2020 iteration too short for him).
I’ll leave it to Simon to offer the final word, but I think I there’s quite a few good options on the market so probably not at this stage 😊
Do you wash these after every wear and so they stand up to that over time. Especially cotton i sometimes find fade and stretch in unattractive ways?
Every one or two wears, but it depends on how hot it was and how long I wore it for.
I think knits perform better when washed and mine have kept their shape well. Colour fade is inevitable over time – especially with cotton. But my dark Anthology and Rubato tees still look good after a couple of years.
The Rubinacci knitted tees are also very nice and worth a shout out. Keen to try the Anthology model and see how the two compare.
Cheers Lachie
A very useful guide thank you. I have been a convert to knitted Ts for a while now, starting with various John Smedley options, but then tried the Rubato t shirt at their recent PS pop up. And proceeded to buy. I absolutely love it, it just feels so elevated worn with trousers or shorts, it had its first run out at Club 55 in St Tropez which I thought was a suitable location!
I have now ordered one of the long sleeve stripe tops from the Yacht Club collection.
I will try Mooncastle too (The Local Merchants were early stockists) and would like to try the Anthology option, but can they be tried on anywhere in London, or just ordered direct?
Thanks MatthewV, just ordered direct.
Thanks Manish
Perhaps it is a good thing that my annual appointment to my ophthalmologist is in a few weeks, but I am confused as to the recommended mink colour for the Connolly t shirt (” I think the mink (top) is very chic”). I just checked the Connolly website; it seems to me that the colour depicted as DARK BROWN on the connollyengland,com website is the same as that which is shown in your article as “MINK.”
On the website MINK is actually a lighter colour brown. Please clarify.
Hi Karl
Sorry for any confusion.
The mink is at the top of the entry, i.e. above the first paragraph on the Connolly t-shirt.
Will a linen knit tee wick moisture better than cotton? Better for hot environments?
Yes, I think so. I don’t think it’ll be a significant difference, and (personally) I find the fit and weight more important.
As someone who would never wear a t-shirt (or non-collared shirt) anywhere but the gym or maaaaaaaybe the beach/pool, I read this and the comments with arms length fascination. Who knows, maybe some day I’ll be comfortable enough to join the club.
It’s all a bit too Miami Vice for me I’m afraid!
@Manish any thoughts on the Adret version of the knitted tee? The proportions are pretty similar to the others on the list but it has an interesting drop-shoulder look
Hi Darius
I bought one about 5/6 years ago and I still wear it a lot.
I’m not sure if the proportions have changed over time, but I believe it is fuller than most of the t-shirts here – my Adret small is similar in width to my medium Rubato.
It’s also longer, has a drop shoulder (as you mention) and longer sleeves which are finished with a really fat rib – so it almost looks like an elevated vintage short sleeve sweatshirt.
It’s a great option and one of the most distinctive around.
Fujito are the best I have found. Very durable.
I have several on this list but I find I reach for my John Smedley ones most. Surprised they weren’t included
Recommend adding Buck Mason to the list when possible – their cashmere/cotton t-shirts are amazing for the price.
Nice! Thanks Thomas.
For lightweight knitted tees I can recommend Gran Sasso’s “fresh cotton”, I love them in spring and summer.
I have tried knitted linen as well but my experience is that the ribbing in linen just does not work properly, even in high quality products it mostly curls on itself. The texture is nice though.
Hello Simon,
Could you please indicate the details of the overshirt over the navy knitted t-shirt in the picture you wear sunglasses?
Thank you in advance.
Hello Manish,
This is a very good and informative list of knitted t-shirts. A new maker for me to consider – Posidonia.
Thank you for that
Hi Adrian
Thanks so much 😊
That is a jacket from Connolly – full details on it are in Simon’s article on knitted t-shirts.
I get mine from 40Colori. Similar price point to The Anthology and a dazzling array of colours to choose from. They do cotton and cotton/cashmere/silk mix, but the latter are very thick and warm, definitely not for the height of summer.
Denzel quote, Max von Sydow playing chess with Death in The Seventh Seal and knitted tees. I must have died and gone to PS heaven!
Haha! Welcome to the PS afterlife 😊
Although I wear button-up bespoke shirts in almost all casual occasions, even in the Summer (because, unlike knits, there is a vast selection of proper shirtings, with optimal quality, for every weather and setting), I find that SEH Kelly in London make by far the best knitted polos and T-shirts.
I don’t find knitted short sleeve t-shirts particularly useful. I have a couple from GRP in linen, and while I think the quality is good and I love wearing them, I just don’t find them cool enough to wear in nyc summers. Even in lower 80s (26-27 C) I find that I sweat a lot in them, unless I wear them for a very short stroll in the shade (on a non-humid day). On the other hand, they are not very good at keeping me warm if temperatures drop under 70 (21C). I definitely can’t say they’re a more luxurious substitute for a usual tee, since I wouldn’t wear these on most days I wear t-shirts.
“This year, they’ve changed the gauge number to improve durability”
Would you mind elaborating on that a little?
The gauge means how densely knitted the material is David, and a denser material will be more robust but also heavier and perhaps warmer
Hi Manish, thanks for another timely and excellent article.
Can I please ask what is the white/cream t-shirt in the very first image of the article (gent with glasses)? That looks great and appears to have a much wider ribbed portion at the bottom?
Thx, GS
Hi GS
That’s Buzz (the cofounder of The Anthology) wearing one of their cream tee-shirts.
I love articles like this on PS. They always introduce some new brands or a new twist on an established item which doubles the fun and usefulness of the article. This time it was the linen knitted t-shirt from Batoner which I now on the waiting list for. Another plus is various price points Manish covers which I am sure is most helpful to us all.
I tried one knitted t-shirt from another Japanese brand, Mooncastle. This is made from Ice Cotton from Spoerry and it was certainly crisp and cool enough from temperatures up to about 30C but after that it was a little too warm especially with the added humidity. I guess it didn’t help when I sized down and bought an L rather than an XL. After a few washes and some shrinkage, it was just too tight and clingy to really wear anymore. Lesson learned.
Cheers Dan 😊
Hi Simon and Manish, what are your thoughts on trousers with both side adjusters and belt loops?
Best of both worlds or compromise without benefit
Hi Northcote
Personally, I think it’s a little overkill. A bit belt-and-braces to use another common phrase.
Exposed throats are mid but not high vibrational. Folks, lets return to mandarin collars, and band collars instead of this rubbish. Even a golf collar polo shirt worn closed collar is a higher frequency at a lower cost.
This is one of those posts where there is plenty to see and learn about, but it’s got nothing to do with the post itself. Many pics feature excellent color and texture blocking, with phenomenal space and rhythm. Wearing tees (even knitted tees) under sport coats, though? Not my cuppa.
Another lovely article Manish!
I’ve been eyeing The Anthology for years but never ordered due to fear of import taxes (as I live in Europe).
Do you buy from a stockist? Though I guess import taxes might be quite different for the UK.
Thank you, Mikkel!
I buy direct, so I totally understand your dilemma.
Thanks for the overview Manish! Do I detect a gap for a PS Finest T-Shirt to fill? I’d be a taker if so. I have 2 of the PS Finest Polos and absolutely love ’em!
Is it possible to stretch out cotton knitted T-shirts like those from anthology and rubato — both horizontally and vertically — when they’re wet after washing? It’s annoying that their lengths are too short on me
I think it’s unlikely Josh unfortunately, and might distort them in other ways potentially too
I’m surprised Mooncastle from Osaka isn’t mentioned. They do a particularly nice 4-ply high twist “ice cotton” and seasonal mixes along with staples. I believe they are the OEM for the Armoury. On the lower end would be Massimo Dutti that has a very wide array every season.
Thanks. Personally I haven’t been that impressed by Mooncastle. A few people have them now but they feel noticeably cheaper to me than other brands here
Have these kinda tshirts been around long?
Do many wesr them?
have to be honest here thinks this looks ridiculous/stupid
dunno why
it aint stunning /fresh / sofisticsted cool / impressing
dont really know why this doesnt work for me just doesnt
It’s quite a traditional look, yes, knitted pieces like this. Not for everyone though certainly
What do you mean with teafitional
i thought this wad a relatively new thing
of course new things can be traditional
were they popular in the 70s or 50s ?
just because something is made in a more elaborate way or with more detail does not make it look good
just looks wrong to me
but hey lotsa people visiting this site seems to enjoy em too
i
I mean knitted things like these were worn in the 30s to the 50s more
It sounds like they’re just not your style, but if you have any specific questions on them, do let me know
You write: “knitted things like these were worn in the 30s”.
So that means different type of garments but knitted ? Were they knitted t-shirts then ?
To me they are not traditional. Traditional to me, means I suppose tried and tested and maybe dressed up in a sense.
I mean you could argue that a mens suit jacket without arms is traditional with a twist (like a suit jacket vest). And that sewn garments like that made out of that kinda materials and with that kinda shape and construction were around in the 1930’s (but they did have arms didn’t they, hence not the same garment).
So, yes I dislike them from an aesthetic point of view and also from the way it makes the wearer look.
I am quite surprised that one would describe the look of knitted t-shirts as “ridiculous/stupid”.
While The Anthology t-shirts certainly have a quite specific look, that one may like or not, most knitted t-shirts are quite subdued. Look at Jon Smedley, or Artknit or Colhay’s. I is a formal step up from a normal t-shirt, but not so different.
I do agree that it is subtle in a sense.
But many subtle changes can make for like a HUGE difference in appearance.
Where the t-shirt is cool, fresh and kinda originally represented rebellion.
I do think the knitted t represents something that is just wrong. It looks wrong it feels wrong.
Just like many people recognize crap art from real quality art I do think most see that the knitted T is just hopelessly uncool and also doesn’t make sense from an aesthetic point of view.
And sure it is subtle changes that makes for this huge difference.
To me, it’s the look of something that is a boring compromise. Not really formal / classical / traditional and also not new / creative / high fashion / cool / stunning .
But I guess this is I partly the nature of many parts of the HUGE business of apparel & fashion. To many labels without a real personality or something of their own, too much copycats a lot of compromise and yes, fear.
Like one could argue that a vest made from a traditional suit jacket is traditional with a twist it still is not a great idea is it.
I tend to agree with Werter. Smart T-shirts seem a bit too much of an oxymoron. If I wanted a smart look, then I would personally want a collar – either a knitted polo or shirt. And for me, the smart t-shirt with tailoring look is a bit ‘fashion’ – go ahead if you can rock it, but those days have well since passed for me!
Hi Manish, what do you think of The Resort Co, cotton/cashmere knitted tee (118 euro) available at https://aroslux.com/products/navy-cotton-cashmere-knitted-t-shirt ? Should I go for offwhite, olive or navy?
Great article, btw 🙏
Hi Ella
That looks nice, and designed a bit more like a regular T-shirt, i.e. the ribbing isn’t super tight or prominent.
All three colours are nice, the navy is probably my favourite. However, I do like the olive as well because it’s a little more unusual.
Hope that helps 🙂
It’s slightly left field, but the loopwheel Real McCoy’s T shirts are worth a look as well. Lovely fit, heavy, structured, and with that particular texture and weave that defines the loopwheel technique.
Thanks Rob – yes good point though I’d put them in a different category almost. Those sweats are kind of heavier and a different type of material
Agreed
This would be an interesting article: A comparison of heavy-loop-wheeled t-shirts (including long-sleeve) and waffle-knits.
Manish, thanks to your article, I picked up two of The Anthology’s knitted tees in ecru and espresso — they fit perfectly and are ideal for Bay Area summers.
Quick question: I have a short torso (part of why I love the cut of these tees), and I find that most regular tees hang well below the fly — especially with high-waisted trousers — which makes wearing them untucked tricky. Do you have any recommendations for more cropped, high-quality tees that work well untucked?
Hello,
we would like to know from where the tan pleated shorts? They look incredible
Hi Msh
The ones in the Rubato entry? They’re from Rubato.
Dear Simon, dear Manish,
I love the look of wearing a t-shirt with tailored jacket or a suit, it is -still- cool. But to my eyes it is something like a dishonest look: You will immediately ruin the collar of your jacket, or not? The sweat, the grease, the dirt, everything will get into the collar, just think about your shirt-collars after a full day in a big city, especially if worn with a tie. Is it really “cool” to wear a tailored jacket just four or three times and then throw it away? This must be the consequence, for even if worn with a shirt the collar of your jacket will become unpleasant with time. Or do have any special trick?, like immediately after wearing having in dry cleaned loosing time and money (not cool either). I have always asked myself that question and never had the courage to wear anything less than a polo-shirt. For the rest, I truly admire your work!
All the best
Jakob
Hi Jakob
It’s a good question and you’re right.
I think the key is to do it sparingly and maybe with a neckerchief to add extra protection – if that’s your style.
Of course, if you’re doing it regularly you’ll probably want to clean it a bit more frequently.
But, the polo shirt and jacket mix is a perfect compromise between a more relaxed look and keeping the jacket clean
Cheers!
Manish
Simon, I have a question on how you wash a Rubato knitted t-shirt. Would 30 degrees of low spinning in the net be good enough? I’m just afraid it will shrink.
Yes that’s fine, it’s what I do with mine
https://www.myntra.com/shirts/rare+rabbit/rare-rabbit-men-alias-n-regular-fit-spread-collar-shirt/29318632/buy?utm_source=dms_google&utm_medium=dms_pmax_cpc&utm_campaign=dms_google_pmax_cpc_Myntra_SOK_East_States_New&keyword=&matchtype=&target=&placement=&gad_source=1&gad_campaignid=22783786046&gbraid=0AAAAADoxBh7QmVZW1hIvljlBjKvkfDoNE&gclid=EAIaIQobChMI776_nsfakAMV7qZmAh0Btx7SEAQYAiABEgIrwvD_BwE
Could you please provide your opinion on these knitted shirts. I am planning to wear it worsted trousers and loafers. Will it look nice or fussy?
It would probably look nice Ayush. I might try slightly more casual trousers – flannels or high twists maybe – at first
Hi Manish,
I am planning to buy a knitted shirt from The Anthology, but struggle a bit with sizing; torn between L and XL.
For reference, I am 6.3; wear shirts in 41 and sports jackets in 50. Any guidance would be much appreciated!
I think you’re probably going to want an XL. Particularly for length, and overall you want the tee to be roomy as well
I love the Robato High Twist, but even trying out the Large and XL, it just fits in a very unusual way, with the tight neck but limited material everywhere else. It is not something I would want to wear once I take my jacket off.
Do you have any recommendations on options – perhaps t shirts? which are more classic shape, still with a good neckline?