john mccabe Whitcomb & Shaftesbury bespoke suit fitting

If you’re looking for a good bespoke suit in London, there aren’t many English options between £1000 and £3000 or so. Most are closer to the £1000 make and finish, but simply charge twice as much.

An interesting option is to have the bespoke cut and finish, but with some parts of the work done abroad. Having one or two of the fittings done in China or India makes a huge difference to the cost, even with the distances the suit will travel.

Kilgour tried this several years ago, but suffered rather from the PR of making in China. That was a shame, because the results were good. Recently a few others have started using a single workshop in China, which also seems to be going well.

I will be trying out some of these over the next few months, as I hope they could offer a good option for someone trying to step up to high-end bespoke, but afraid of the tripling in price. For clarity and consistency, I will refer to this service as ‘foreign bespoke’.


Suresh Ramakrishnan

In this post we will be looking at Whitcomb & Shaftesbury. Despite the name, W&S is run by two Indian brothers, Suresh (above) and Mahesh Ramakrishnan. They have a nice room on the top of 11 St George St (the same building as Steven Hitchcock, on the ground floor).

Their cutter is John McCabe (pictured top), who has been cutting around Savile Row for 40 years – at J. Dege & Sons and at Kilgour from 1993 to 2010.

Suresh manages most of the operations in London, and is effectively front of house. Importantly, he offers two services – both with John cutting, but one where the suit is entirely made in London with standard tailors, and the other where most is made in the brothers’ workshop in India.


Whitcomb & Shaftesbury

In my experience this is important because over time it brings the two offerings closer together. The same cutting is going into each, and you expect the same coat-making to come back. At every stage, John is comparing the work of both local and foreign makers and bringing them to the same standard.

The two offerings are referred to as Savile Row Bespoke and Classic Bespoke, and cost £3040 and £1360 respectively (both exclusive of VAT). It’s quite a cost saving; and given that I’ve always said the fit is the most important thing, it makes the latter a great introductory option.


john mccabe Whitcomb & Shaftesbury

I try to be cold and objective about these things, but it might also matter that Suresh and Mahesh’s workshop was set up in the wake of the 2004 tsunami, in order to offer training and work to fishermen that had lost their livelihoods. Since 2009, it has turned to helping abused and deprived women. Around 300 people have been trained in that time, of which 70 work there today.

From what I’ve seen so far, the craftsmanship is on the same level as London. Indeed, the women in India are often able to take on things that some coatmakers would not, such as lapped seams and embroidery.

One jacket (below) features two strips of leather embedded down the front of a jacket. It’s not really my taste, and the work wasn’t perfect, but that kind of range enables Suresh to offer unusual details and very low prices.

I was going to have one suit made in the Classic Bespoke, but Suresh offered to make me the Savile Row level as well, in order to compare the workmanship in each. It will be interesting to see how they turn out.


Whitcomb & Shaftesbury scarf jacket
Subscribe
Notify of
guest
66 Comments
Oldest
Newest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
J

Looks like a good concept, but I don’t really get why they wouldn’t use their ‘own’ names as opposed to a fictitious one?

At one point I was expecting to read they had bought out an ailing firm, which is normally the case with such things.

I have absolutely no doubt an Indian or Chinese (or insert other) based national could do just as good a job as a Savile Row tailor, but something about the naming thing always rings alarm bells when companies do this sort of thing. Like the ‘Savile Row Company’ of America which sells cheap shirts to unsuspecting Americans.

Surely better to just call it by their own surnames or similar combination?

It’s a subtle thing, but I do think branding and dare I say it ‘authenticity’ is important in this level of price point. And yes, I am aware Chinese conglomerates own Hardy Amies etc, but my response would be that at least someone of that name founded the company…

Litigator

J – quite right. I spent several years genuinely convinced that Aquascutum’s heritage dated back to 75 AD, in the belief that they were behind some of the first water-repellent togas in Ancient Rome. Words cannot express the disappointment I felt upon learning that the brand was merely created less than two centuries ago.

culverwood

John McCabe cut some suits for me at Carr Son and Woor many years ago. I will be interested to hear how this experiment turns out as if the quality of both are very similar I may try them.

Rabster

Very good topic you’ve opened with this article.
Like many who read your blog with a limited budget I think this sort of venture by Whitcomb & Shaftesbury will be of great interest.
I agree with J , why the ‘hiding’ behind the name, only has this is the thing often associated with Far East Tailors selling a Saville ‘Rowesque’ service.
I note that Thomas Mahon (English Cut) was also going to start a similar venture. Maybe a comparison with that is in order ?
In addition , with more and more offshoring of manufacture (e.g. Grenson Shoes etc) , beyond the patriotic argument does it really matter if the stitching is done in the UK or India or China ? Especially when affordability is a major criteria.

Really looking forward to hearing your no holds barred style of review on this .

Colin

Hi Simon….unrelated to this post what are your thoughts on shoe colors other than the many shades of brown and black: specifically I’m thinking green, grey and darker maroons/plums, all of which I’ve seen in various Edward Green and Meermin models? Thank you. Colin

Mark

Thank you for taking this project on, Simon. I think you have a difficult job on the blog in maintaining a focus on true craft and luxury while not completely alienating people (like me) who can’t afford some of the more expensive bespoke options.

It’s difficult to find reviews/opinions of these services from people with enough experience of bespoke quality to offer an informed view, and yet intuitively this seems like it should be the value sweet-spot for men of more modest means.

Thanks again, and I’m looking forward to your reviews.

Richard

Am a huge fan of this site, and like and value’s Simon’s opinion, but I’m not sure he needs thanks for ‘taking’ a project ‘on’ that gets him £5K worth of quality clothing….. Even if it is selfless of him to do this. Haha. Naturally, I look forward to reading Simon’s take on the company…..

Richard

Was only teasing the poster, Simon. Not you. Really enjoy reading you. Best commentator online on this subject.

Frank

Hmm, I wonder if any of these 70 Indian women ever will be able to buy their own products? If you say that does not matter, then I wonder what kind of relationship these women ever get to the products they make? Compare that to the interacting world of cutters and tailors (even those working from home) in London, then one must conclude there is very little bespoke about it. Foreign bespoke? No sir, from a customer’s point of view this operation is all about making more profit and the idea of bespoke is corrupted. If only the quality matters, then I’d say the working conditions of these women do to. After all, that is why “real bespoke” is so expensive.

Omar Ali

Indian bespoke tailors in Dubai charge about 800 to 1000 GBP for bespoke suitssuits, would love to hear if you have experience with them? Or heard reviews?

lsp

I look forward to your experience with this; I agree that there is no inherent reason that a suit made in Location A should be superior to one made in Location B. It all comes down to the quality of the work and the way the process is set up. I think there are challenges that distant production creates, but those challenges should be manageable if properly addressed. Also, remember that many (most?) London bespoke firms use outworkers, which approach creates its own challenges. It sounds like the Indian production may be under one roof, which has benefits in terms of quality control, process efficiency, and perhaps process improvement/learning.

Simon — one nit to pick: you continue to use the words ‘that’ and ‘which’ to refer to people, whereas ‘who’ and ‘whom’ is appropriate. For example, in this piece, “… of which 70 work there today …” Based on a bit of Googling, which should not refer to people. The use of ‘that’ in reference to people apparently is grammatically acceptable but is jarring to my (overly sensitive?) ears.

Murray

Hello Simon
Thanks very much for a wonderful website,i love it.
I have just purchased some light grey Flannel trousers from Ralph Lauren and was wondering what your advice would be,as to whether i should have a turn up or not and if so what depth?
These will mostly be worn with Edward Greens and possibly some Sanders Hi tops.
Look forward to your views
Regards
Murray

BespokeNYC

Very interesting concept – I’ll be curious to see how the results turn out. I completely agree that, in theory, there’s no reason Indian (or any other nationality) tailors shouldn’t be able to achieve the same results with the right training and quality controls. That said, it’s fascinating to see the strength of the relationship between apprentice and master tailor. (The Armoury’s documentary on Antonio Liverano shows this very well in the way he works with Taka and Qemal.)

Perhaps I’m being overly sentimental but I imagine the same type of relationship is harder to achieve with this type of outsourcing arrangement, and this in turn might affect the quality of the final product?

Matt

Sounds very similar to Cad & the Dandy and my experience of their output has been decidedly mixed. I’ll be interested to see how this one works out.

As for the reader who mentioned Thomas Mahon – I would caution against using his newly launched online M2M as you’re unlikely to see your suits for several months, if it all. I ended up demanding a refund after waiting over 9 months for a first fitting. Total disaster.

Wes wp

Hello again, Simon. I always look forward to your posts.

Given the exorbitant cost of bespoke tailoring (even $2700 USD is a princely sum), I don’t understand why people don’t research (and personally experience) RTW and OTR makers. Given enough experimentation, one will inevitably find the right “block” for their body type. I could be the “fit model” for two Italian brands (for instance).

In reference to posters who say this “foreign bespoke” is helpful for the budget conscious man…I do quite well for myself, and I must tell you that $2700 USD is hardly fitting into my budget. I would rather buy from an ebay seller like Sartoriale, who offer new, unworn suits, take them to my tailor, and I have the perfectly fitted suit (again – it’s two makers for me that – essentially – have the ideal block/pattern).

Their suits are almost always under 500 pounds (1K USD), and the handwork and craftsmanship is second to few.

I get the whole enterprise of selecting your fabrics and trimmings, and having a garment that fits you well, allows for freedom of movement, (et al), but Uman suits (for instance) are ideal for many men “right off the peg.” That was Uman’s quest in the first place – to measure 100000 Italian men to arrive at the ideal “suit block pattern.”

It’s one thing to want quality and great fit, it’s another thing to pay a third of your monthly salary to get there.

Moreover, a bespoke suit often does not last – especially if rendered in cashmere or flannel. You’re lucky to get 2 – 3 years out of the garment. And – at those prices – it’s a losing proposition when you have so many wonderful OTR options.

David Craggs

Simon is correct. It will never match bespoke.
Regarding what it’s worth, I once had to endure a never ending lecture about the cost of my shoes from a friend who has a garage full of cars he never drives (his wife loved my shoes and asked the price and I made the mistake of telling her).
Everybody has their thing and their limits. Self imposed or otherwise. Personally, I’d rather have a few well made items that I love and which I wear regularly than a wardrobe full of average stuff.
I’m no fan of consumertitus but for me bespoke is something that I love and appreciate.

Darren K

Dear Simon – Thank you for this post. I’ll await your comments. I wonder what you think about their process with overseas visits? If the suits they make you meet your criteria/expectations, should we think that the end result would be similar if we have them make a suit during a visit to the US?

KP

Thanks for this post, Simon.
1. To answer J on why they used a different compared to their original ones- the surnames are Ramakrishnan (and mine is equally long coming from Chennai,too!). With such long names as ours, the cost to put it on the suit would be higher than the suit itself! Jokes apart, but guess they must have their own reasons.
2. I know where their suit-making unit in Chennai is, and it is NOT in one of the “sneeze-and-it’ll-fall” spots. So the working conditions are akin to what you’d experience in London.
On a side note, this is a really great initiative of 2 brothers (one an ex-banker and the other an ex-management consultant) to actually make a difference. So for now, I will applaud them and get back to work, in order to be able afford their offerings (among the multiple other stupendously beautiful things Simon educates us on).

David Craggs

This is interesting and the outcome will be fascinating.
That said, I prefer — whenever possible — to buy products made in the UK.
Failing that , Italy gets the rest of my sartorial dollars.

Michael

I agree it is a pity that they are using a generic sounding name & don’t feel able to use their own names or something that represents them more authentically. Simon apologies if you have covered this before but could you expand on your point about the 3D nature of bespoke? Thanks.

Nicholas M

Hi Simon – looking forward to seeing how your suits progress. Some years ago I had two suits made by Kilgour in China – one of which was cut by John McCabe. Both were great but unwearable now as I was a bigger man back then.

Snapper

Simon I have used this service from W & S and was not disappointed. Initially I was shown examples of both Bespokes without knowing which was which and asked if I could detect any quality differences between the UK and Indian made versions. I could not and therefore went for the less expensive option for my commision. It turned out to be perfect.

I look forward to your conclusions.

Oliver

Simon – you mention that “Most are closer to the £1000 make and finish, but simply charge twice as much.”

Would you be willing to name any of the London-based tailors who you would classify on this basis? I appreciate that you have previously indicated a reluctance to criticise, but I – and I’m sure other readers – would be interested to know which tailors you don’t think provide value for money.

Sam

Hi Simon,
How would you describe the construction of their house style? From the photos it perhaps looks a little more structured than what you would normally go for.
Cheers,
Sam

Bruce B

Simon: Who is the “one workshop” mentioned in China people are using

Anonymous

Simon, thanks for this article – very interesting. As always with this topic there is great interest in quality RTW & MTM. I think, with readers help perhaps, that it might be a good project to coordinate a list of tailors outside of SR. There are also many good bespoke tailors across the UK that might be worthy of consideration. Michelsberg in Leeds comes to mind as an example where quality (from reviews) seems high but at a similar price to that of Graham Browne. Just a thought but it might prove to be greatly useful for readers.

Matt

Good idea and something which certainly would be useful for those of us who don’t spend much time down south.

P.S. Michelsberg in Leeds is to be avoided. He has a flashy website and good online presence but he’s no tailor. His suits are all made by Carl Stuart in Ossett. Order from him and you’re paying an extra £300 – £500 for the privilege of having your measurements taken in a swanky shop in the Victoria Quarter.

Adam Jones

One thing I keep picking up on in this article is the fact you say most london tailors give you a £1000 but just charge more. As you know I am just about to have my first consultation in the next few weeks for my first bespoke suit. I did debate for ages between tailors. I couldn’t decide if it it was worthwhile going to someone like sweeneys, Everest, Powell etc or just giving graham browne a go. I decided to go to stay away from the city in the end but now you have me questioning my choice…again!

Anonymous

It’s absolutely not true to say that you get the same quality suit, whether made in India or London. I’ve seen both versions.

The Indian-made version offers a cheaper alternative if price is your God. It’s not even close to the London-made option in quality. The London-made option is not simply a more pricey version of the same thing. It’s bona fide bespoke from a top-drawer cutter and made by SR craftsmen.

Snapper

Simon Anonymous must be a very astute tailoring expert if he could spot £1600 worth of quality difference in the two W & S suits cut by John.

Regards, Snapper

Robbert Tan

Dear Simon,

I live in the Netherlands, and there basically aren’t any bespoke tailors here as far as I can tell. I suppose I could travel to London, but I would much rather like to make an appointment with a travelling tailor in Amsterdam. Could you recommend someone?

Kind regards,

Robbert Tan

Will

Sorry if this is the wrong thread but is any one as appalled as I am at how awful Daniel Craig looked in his Tom Ford getup? I heard Mr Ford paid a certain consideration ($7 million?) for the right to dress Mr Craig and, well, so be it. But this “skinny boy” look while sharp to the majority of the average viewer felt a betrayal of all that Bond stands for, viz., The Best of British. And those shirt collars? I know that this sort of filmmaking is a commercial venture but I did fell a little sorry that he couldn’t have looked a little more Mallory (M) or Kingsman.

twitter_LeeAlexander71

Dear Simon, all interesting, but given that the ‘fast fashion’ side of the industry is based on low wages, poor working conditions etc,… which we are trying to fix; it would be shame for bespoke to be heading down the same outsourcing route. Does W&S assure that workers in India have a decent wage and good working conditions?, and no child labour? Although of course low wages etc are a problem on the row and have been for years (ref: Richard Andersons book of course). Given the increasing interest of the apparel and fashion industry in sustainability, bespoke should be the pinnacle of a sustainable approach to dress. Cheers, Lee

Bob

I was wondering if you had a view on opening hours? I know no one wants to work weekends etc but I would have thought most those considering bespoke suits work themselves and probably in the types of jobs that are typically “mon-fri, 9-5”. Whilst a few SR tailors are open Saturday mornings many arent, including W&S, and so they’re limiting themselves to those who work within 15 minutes of the shop.

There are a couple of tailors I’d like to try, including W&S, but being ~1hr15 round trip from Canary Wharf before factoring in waiting time/fitting time etc and the 2hr lunch is something of the past in my industry I simply cannot use these companies. Do they have so much business they don’t need to consider those outside W1 or the independently wealthy?

VK

Hi Simon

Not sure if you’ve done a review of Cad & the Dandy, but do you have any comments/thoughts on their fully bespoke offering (which in some cases appears to be in the price range of the Classic Bespoke offering by W&S)?

VK

Thanks Simon, appreciate the feedback.

Abhi

Hi Simon,

Would you recommend WnS for a sports jacket( something like a blue flannel) or is it better to go for a formal 2 piece suit as a first?

Abhi

Thanks Simon, so you would recommend something like worsted wool or cashmere?

owr

appreciate this post is a few years old now but do you have any experience with the bespoke shirts offered by w&s? or at least know what sort of price point they are offered at

Anonymous

Hello there,
A friend of mine and I recently had a classic bespoke suite made at W&S. Quite to our surprise, the 1st fitting suits were, for the two of us, not made with the fabric we picked, but with a cheaper cloth, not at all the kind of picture we could see in this article, or others on this blog. Since it was our first bespoke experience, is that normal procedure?